Skip to content

Something urgent? Call us now! (852) 3416 1711

Proposed noise law ‘difficult to enforce’

Hong Kong, 15 August 2023: Education is more effective than legislation when it comes to keeping a lid on noise in vibrant Hong Kong, BC&C Senior Partner Colin Cohen has told radio listeners.

Colin was a guest on RTHK Radio 3’s Backchat to discuss government proposals to amend the Noise Control Ordinance (Cap 400) to curb the use of loudspeakers by shops and hawkers for peddling, introduce a fixed penalty system and adjust maximum fines.

“We live in a crowded, vibrant city of more than seven million people, there is bound to be noise and tensions that arise as a result. I think education and trying to encourage people to keep noise levels down is far better than legislation and fixed penalties,” Colin told presenters Danny Gittings and Mike Rowse.

He noted the proposed legislation targeted a specific group of citizens and asked: “Is there really a significant problem here?” As for the suggestion that the fixed penalties – set at HK$10,000 “to enhance the deterrent effect”, according to the government – could be extended to domestic premises, Colin thought this would be difficult to enforce.

He added: “Of course, the major noise issue in Hong Kong is construction, this is what really affects people’s mental health. Obviously, you need old buildings to be knocked down and new ones constructed, but some sites, especially those operated by smaller firms, do not have effective noise barriers. The proposed legislation does not address construction work.”

Aside from limiting the use of loudspeakers, the government is also proposing to relax restrictions on noise resulting from certain festivals, allowing activities held in places of public entertainment to continue after 11:00pm under specific conditions. It has launched a two-month public consultation on its proposals.

Colin’s fellow guests on the programme were clinical psychologist Dr Quratulain Zaidi and events professional Robert Rogers.

38+ years of legal experience is just a click away.

Friendly and approachable, we are ready to answer your questions and offer you sound advice.

Contact us now

BC&C-contact-us

News & Knowledge

Learn more about what we do and what we say. Subscribe to our newsletter to ensure you receive our updates.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Law & More: Episode 31 – Mike Riley

Hong Kong, 28 September 2023: This time on Law & More, we welcome an old friend of the firm and someone who loves visiting Hong Kong, former English Premier League referee Mike Riley. In a wide-ranging discussion, Mike reflects on memorable moments in his career, his recently relinquished role as general manager of the elite […]

Read more

Fancy footwork from our finance chief

Grindelwald, Switzerland, 20 September 2023: Don your best threads and polish your dance moves, because night fever is coming to Hong Kong. That’s right, my groovy friends, we may be lacking a Bee Gees soundtrack and the flare-wearing 70s are long gone but – just like John Travolta in his career-making role – our leaders […]

Read more

Landslide exposes prosecution risk

By Alex Liu Hong Kong, 18 September 2023: Owners of luxury properties that are illegally modified or encroach on government land should brace for swift enforcement action from the authorities after the much-publicised landslide at Redhill Peninsula. Chief Executive John Lee has warned his administration will “take action in accordance with the law”, including prosecuting […]

Read more

BC&C lawyers attend wills briefing

Hong Kong, 13 September 2023: Boase Cohen & Collins lawyers were brought up to date on matters concerning wills, probate and estate administration when the firm hosted an in-house seminar. Our legal team heard from barristers Ken To and Matthew Choi, both of Sir Oswald Cheung’s Chambers, who gave a presentation on recent judgments and […]

Read more

NSL judges given sentencing flexibility

By Colin Cohen Hong Kong, 11 September 2023: A landmark Court of Final Appeal (CFA) judgment has provided welcome clarity regarding sentencing guidelines in national security cases. While confirming that mandatory minimum sentences are indeed mandatory, the top court has given judges leeway to consider – as they do in non-national security hearings – a […]

Read more