Skip to content

Something urgent? Call us now! (852) 3416 1711

When the deceased may not have final say

When the deceased may not have final say

Inheritance or financial disputes can add to the pain of a spouse or close relative’s passing. Boase Cohen & Collins Partner Fiona Chan outlines the legal options available to anyone who wishes to challenge a Will or the rules of intestacy.

Hong Kong, 5 February 2020: Bereavement brings considerable grief and stress, but imagine how these feelings are exacerbated if there are complications over inheritance of the deceased’s estate.

The general rule is that everyone has “testamentary freedom”, meaning they have the right to leave their assets to whomever they wish. But what if your recently-passed loved one has not included you as a beneficiary in their Will, or has not left you what you were expecting? What if they have died without leaving a Will and the rules of intestacy mean you are not among the beneficiaries?

In such circumstances, an aggrieved person can apply to the Court for reasonable financial provision from the deceased’s estate under section 4 of the Inheritance (Provision for Family and Dependants) Ordinance (Cap. 481). Those who can apply are the deceased’s wife or husband, female or male civil partner, or anyone who was being maintained, either wholly or substantially, by the deceased immediately before their death.

What is reasonable financial provision? The Court has wide discretion but is guided by section 3(2) of the Ordinance which states that if the applicant is the deceased’s spouse or civil partner, the Court does not have to consider whether the provision is needed for maintenance. For other applicants, however, the Court needs to be convinced that the provision is for maintenance.

If the Court is satisfied there should be reasonable financial provision for the applicant, it can order periodical payments from the estate, or a lump sum, or for the transfer or settlement of certain property of the estate.

However, before making any order, the Court has to consider the financial resources and needs not only of the applicant, but also those of any other applicants or beneficiaries, whether the deceased had any obligations or responsibilities to any applicants or beneficiaries, and the size and nature of the estate. The Court can also take into account any other factors, including the conduct of the applicant or other individuals, which it feels is relevant.

It should also be noted that the Court has discretion to order interim maintenance. It can do so if the applicant is in immediate need of financial assistance but it is not yet possible to determine what order (if any) should be made. In such circumstances, the Court also needs to see that property forming part of estate is, or can be, made available to meet the applicant’s needs.

The Judge in ACLS v HSB(T)L [2013] 2 HKLRD 444 referred to Barnsley v Ward (unrep., Eng CA, 8 January 1980) where the Judge set out the three hurdles the applicant has to overcome for interim maintenance:-

  • the applicant must show that he/she is in immediate need;
  • there is property forming part of the estate which is or can be made available to meet that need; and
  • the applicant must satisfy the Court that it is right in the circumstances to exercise the Court’s discretion and make an order in the manner sought.

Finally, is there a time limit for such matters? Under section 6 of the Ordinance, the applicant must apply to the Court within six months from the date on which a grant of representation is first taken out. However, it has discretion to accept late applications.

Fiona Chan specialises in dispute resolution and is experienced in a wide range of civil litigation. Her core practice areas include Will drafting, estate administration and probate matters, while she is an appointed member of the Panel Solicitors for the Official Administrator. She can be contacted at fionachan@boasecohencollins.com.

Estate PHOTO

The principle of “testamentary freedom” is central to the drafting and enforcement of a Will.

37+ years of legal experience is just a click away.

Friendly and approachable, we are ready to answer your questions and offer you sound advice.

Contact us now

BC&C-contact-us

News & Knowledge

Learn more about what we do and what we say. Subscribe to our newsletter to ensure you receive our updates.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

IP issues aired at Copenhagen conference

Hong Kong, 20 June 2022: Our Partner Susan Cheung was among hundreds of delegates who converged on Copenhagen for the 40th annual conference of ECTA – the European Communities Trademark Association. With a theme of “Designing the Future”, the four-day gathering brought together intellectual property professionals in a series of presentations, panel discussions and workshops, […]

Read more

Eureka! Another really bad idea …

Paris, 15 June 2022: Albert Einstein was a refugee. The feted physicist and Nobel laureate arrived in the US in 1933 after fleeing persecution in Nazi Germany. Singer Freddie Mercury, painter Marc Chagall, American Secretary of State Madeleine Albright and philanthropist George Soros? Refugees all. Just a few notable names – and there are many […]

Read more

Fostering a spirit of togetherness

By Allison Lee Hong Kong, 10 June 2022: A modest but significant ceremony was staged by the Social Welfare Department (SWD) last month to celebrate a group of unsung heroes of the pandemic, namely foster families. The dedication shown by foster parents and, in many cases, their birth children in providing a temporary home for […]

Read more

A directive for the digital age

By Arthur Chan and Jasmine Kwong Hong Kong, 8 June 2022: Over the past few years, tensions have been prevalent in Hong Kong society due to the city’s political situation. Although the role of the Judiciary is defined so as to remain impartial and unbiased, it is impossible to untwine politics and justice. Judges and […]

Read more

Lessons in life from a legendary teacher

Hong Kong, 7 June 2022: Inspirational teacher and charity worker Nicole Sicard recounted her remarkable life story in a lunchtime talk at the Helena May in Central attended by five of BC&C’s lawyers. During a fireside chat with our Partner Usha Casewell, Miss Sicard described how she arrived in Hong Kong almost 60 years ago […]

Read more