Skip to content

Something urgent? Call us now! (852) 3416 1711

LGBTQ+ activists win landmark ruling

By Gabriella Chan

Hong Kong, 7 September 2023: The Court of Final Appeal (CFA) has handed a partial – but still significant – victory to Hong Kong’s LGBTQ+ community this week by ruling that the government has not fulfilled its constitutional duty to provide a legal framework for recognising same-sex relationships. The top court has suspended its declaration for two years to give the administration time to come up with such a mechanism.

In its judgment, delivered on Tuesday, the CFA unanimously ruled against recognising same-sex marriage. However, by a three to two majority, it declared the authorities had failed to establish an alternative regime for legally acknowledging same-sex relationships, such as registered civil partnerships or unions.

Background

The case was brought by gay activist Jimmy Sham, who married his partner in the United States in 2013, a union that is not recognised under Hong Kong law. He applied for a judicial review in 2018 for a declaration that local laws were unconstitutional since they recognised foreign heterosexual marriages but not same-sex ones such as his.

Sham – former convenor of the now-disbanded Civil Human Rights Front and currently remanded under the national security law – saw his application dismissed by the Court of First Instance and Court of Appeal but was granted leave to take his case to the CFA.

The top court was asked to rule on three questions framed within the provisions of the Basic Law and Bill of Rights: first, whether there is a constitutional right to same-sex marriage; second, whether the absence of any alternative means of legal recognition of same-sex relationships is a violation of the right to equality; and third, whether the non-recognition of foreign same-sex marriage is a violation of the right to equality.

CFA ruling

With regard to questions one and three, the judges were in agreement that the constitutional freedom of marriage guaranteed under the Basic Law and Bill of Rights is confined to opposite-sex unions, thus overriding equality protection in that legislation.

On question two, the court acknowledged by majority the need of same-sex couples for access to an alternative legal framework in order to meet basic social requirements and to have a sense of legitimacy which dispels any sense of them belonging to an inferior class of persons. “[T]he absence of legal recognition has been seen to be essentially discriminatory and demeaning to same-sex couples,” the judgement read.

The judges accepted the government would have flexibility in deciding the content of the recognition to be devised, including a “core” of rights necessary for establishing the legal framework.

Summary

In the absence of affirmative government policy to protect the rights of Hong Kong’s LGBTQ+ community, campaigners have been achieving piecemeal change through the judicial system. This week’s CFA ruling is a notable landmark. It could, potentially, pave the way for same-sex couples – who currently face various obstacles in their daily lives – to enjoy many of the marital entitlements given to their heterosexual counterparts.

In saying this, however, it should be stressed that we have no idea what sort of “alternative framework” the authorities will propose. There is risk that any attempt to draw narrow parameters will simply invite further litigation. It is expected the authorities may take a long time to establish a comprehensive system to recognise same-sex relationships. Nonetheless, it is pleasing to see our society moving, albeit slowly, towards becoming an all-inclusive one. 

For now, at least, the CFA is compelling the government to act. We await developments with interest and anticipation.

Gabriella Chan is a Senior Associate with BC&C. She focuses her practice on Family Law, being proficient in a wide range of matters arising from the matrimonial context, and is also active in the Hong Kong Family Law Association. She can be contacted at Gabriella@boasecohencollins.com.

39+ years of legal experience is just a click away.

Friendly and approachable, we are ready to answer your questions and offer you sound advice.

Contact us now

BC&C-contact-us

News & Knowledge

Learn more about what we do and what we say. Subscribe to our newsletter to ensure you receive our updates.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Updating copyright for the AI landscape

By Susan Cheung and Nicole Chin Hong Kong, 7 October 2024: The Commerce and Economic Development Bureau and the Intellectual Property Department have jointly published a consultation paper, taking a significant step towards modernising Hong Kong’s copyright regime in response to the rapid advancements in artificial intelligence (AI). The paper addresses key issues regarding copyright […]

Read more

Ian McWalters delivers compelling talk

Hong Kong, 2 October 2024: A large audience gathered at the University of Hong Kong to hear former Justice of Appeal Ian McWalters deliver the sixth annual HKU-Boase Cohen & Collins Criminal Law Lecture. His talk, “The Exercise of Discretion in the Criminal Justice System”, examined discretionary decision making by law enforcement, prosecutors and judicial […]

Read more

The blurred lines of ‘medical beauty’

By Teresa Leung Hong Kong, 25 September 2024: Our city’s largely unregulated “medical beauty” industry is back in the news following the jailing of a beautician over a botched botox injection. It is the latest in a string of cases featuring unlicensed medical practices – some of them leading to permanent physical damage or even […]

Read more

Law & More: Episode 44 – Jennifer Bourke

Hong Kong, 24 September 2024: In the latest episode, we are delighted to meet Jennifer Bourke, the Consul General of Ireland to Hong Kong and Macao. With a busy schedule that mixes politics, business and culture, Jennifer is loving life in Hong Kong, where she embraces the city’s energy, works closely with the Irish community […]

Read more

Migrant worker issues ‘go back decades’

Hong Kong, 19 September 2024: Rogue middlemen continue to get away with exploiting imported workers in Hong Kong and stronger government regulation is needed to combat such behaviour, Colin Cohen has told radio listeners. Reacting to recent allegations of malpractice in the construction industry, he said: “These stories are not new and it is not […]

Read more