Skip to content

Something urgent? Call us now! (852) 3416 1711

Helpers’ hardships highlighted in lecture

Hong Kong, 11 November 2021: Melville Boase called upon four decades of experience in dealing with migrant worker issues when he gave a lecture to University of Hong Kong students this week about the difficulties faced by domestic helpers in the territory.

Mel, co-founder of Boase Cohen & Collins in 1985, detailed the three core issues which cause problems for the helper community: being asked to work outside the terms of their contact; the so-called “two week” rule which stipulates helpers must leave Hong Kong within a fortnight of termination of their employment for whatever reason; and the requirement for helpers to live with their employers.

His talk, “Second Class Citizens”, also highlighted how the government fails to properly regulate employers and employment agencies, with the latter often guilty of overcharging helpers for placing them in work, and turns a blind eye to serious overcrowding in boarding houses for helpers who are between contracts. In addition, his lecture highlighted examples of discriminatory Covid-19 testing and quarantine policies.

He concluded: “When it comes to overseas workers here, including domestic helpers, there are laws on the statute but they are not enforced. Our government also has obligations under international labour conventions, but is somewhat lax in enforcing them. The result? Our 370,000 helpers, whose presence contributes so much to Hong Kong’s economy by allowing their employers to go out to work, are treated differently from the rest of us. Second class citizens, indeed.”

Mel helped set up the Mission For Migrant Workers in 1981 and has served continuously as the organisation’s Treasurer since then. While he officially retired from BC&C two years ago, both he and the firm remain strongly committed to the cause of migrant workers and ensuring they have access to justice.

The lecture formed part of a course within HKU’s Faculty of Law run by the Global Migration Legal Clinic, which was created to address labour migration abuses, human trafficking and modern slavery.

40+ years of legal experience is just a click away.

Friendly and approachable, we are ready to answer your questions and offer you sound advice.

Contact us now

BC&C-contact-us

News & Knowledge

Learn more about what we do and what we say. Subscribe to our newsletter to ensure you receive our updates.

  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Hearsay evidence reform in pipeline

By Arthur Chan and Jasmine Kwong Hong Kong 2 July 2026: After years of deliberation, steps are being taken to reform the rule against hearsay in criminal proceedings in Hong Kong. The move has been widely welcomed by professional legal bodies, academics and the Judiciary as being in the best interests of justice. The Evidence (Amendment) Bill […]

Read more

A landmark moment? Watch this space

Dallas, 17 June 2026: As spring turned to summer in 1961, President John F. Kennedy famously stood before Congress and declared the USA should seek to land a man on the moon by the decade’s end. “No single space project in this period will be more impressive to mankind or more important for the long […]

Read more

New commercial court is welcome news

By Alex Liu and John Zhou Hong Kong, 16 June 2026: In a welcome development, the Judiciary has unveiled plans to establish the Hong Kong International Commercial Court, a specialist division of the High Court, to adjudicate complex, high-value international and cross-border commercial disputes. The move will strengthen this city’s standing as both a global […]

Read more

Law & More: Episode 67 – Queenie Lau SC

Hong Kong, 15 June 2026: This episode features Senior Counsel Queenie Lau, who reflects on her early years at boarding school in the UK, university days at Cambridge and her subsequent career in the legal profession, including her initial steps as a corporate solicitor before deciding her future lay at the Bar. Queenie speaks with […]

Read more

Addressing ‘illegality’ in cross-border disputes

By Alex Liu and Arthur Chan Hong Kong, 3 June 2026: In a judgment carrying huge significance for cross-border transactions, the Court of Final Appeal has ruled that claims for unjust enrichment should not be fatally undermined when an agreement between parties is tainted by illegality. The ruling makes clear that Hong Kong courts should […]

Read more